April 16, 2026
Federal Sentencing
The Fifth Circuit on Career Offender Sentences: What Defendants Need to Know About Reasonableness Review
A February 2026 Fifth Circuit decision drives home a point every federal defendant — and every federal defense lawyer — needs to understand before sentencing: disagreeing with how the district court weighed the § 3553(a) factors is not the same as showing the sentence was unreasonable. In United States v. Williams, No. 25-30347 (5th Cir. Feb. 13, 2026), the court affirmed a 240-month sentence for a career offender convicted of methamphetamine distribution, despite extensive arguments that the district court had underweighted the defendant’s substantial assistance to the government, his addiction history, his age, and the nonviolent character of his prior record.
The Fifth Circuit applied a rebuttable presumption of reasonableness to the below-guidelines sentence and declined to reweigh the district court’s calculus. Citing United States v. Douglas, 957 F.3d 602 (5th Cir. 2020), the court reiterated that appellate review is “highly deferential” because the sentencing court is in a better position to find facts and judge their importance under § 3553(a). Arguments that mirror what was already made to the district court will not succeed on appeal.
The practical lesson is that the sentencing hearing itself is the main event. By the time a sentence is on appeal, the record is fixed. The arguments that matter — substantial assistance, personal history, the age and nonviolent character of prior convictions, below-guidelines data for similarly situated defendants — must be built into the sentencing memorandum and argued with specificity before the district court. Preserving disagreement for appeal, without a developed record to support it, leaves the Fifth Circuit little to do but affirm.
April 16, 2026
Constitutional
Fourth Amendment in the Fifth Circuit: Why “Clearly Established Law” Controls — and What That Means for Suppression
A January 2026 Fifth Circuit decision clarifies how narrowly federal courts apply the Fourth Amendment where officer safety is at stake — with direct implications for federal criminal practice. Officers conducting a high-risk stop while searching for an armed fugitive handcuffed a bystander for approximately six minutes. He suffered serious physical harm requiring surgery. The district court denied qualified immunity based on a factual dispute about whether officers knew of his medical condition before restraining him. The Fifth Circuit reversed.
The controlling question, the court explained, is not whether the officer’s conduct caused harm or whether a different approach might have been safer. The question is whether the conduct violated clearly established law at the time of the encounter — meaning prior precedent must place the constitutional question “beyond debate.” Without a closely analogous prior decision, qualified immunity applies. The court also held that disclosing a medical condition does not automatically alter the analysis; the law must specifically and clearly require a different response under those circumstances.
For defendants seeking suppression in federal criminal cases, the principle is the same. Broad Fourth Amendment propositions rarely prevail in the Fifth Circuit. Courts look for concrete, on-point authority matching the specific circumstances of the search or seizure at issue. This makes early factual development of a suppression motion essential: how the search unfolded, the precise justification officers asserted, the sequence of events, and the duration and scope of any detention are the details on which motions to suppress turn. The argument must be built from the facts up — not from general constitutional principles down.
April 16, 2026
Grand Jury
You Just Received a Federal Target Letter. Here Is What It Means and What to Do Next.
A federal target letter is a written notice from the United States Attorney’s Office informing you that you are the target of a federal grand jury investigation — meaning the government believes it has substantial evidence linking you to a federal crime. By the time that letter arrives, federal agents have typically been working the case for months, sometimes years. They have reviewed financial records, interviewed witnesses, analyzed communications, and built a file. The letter is not a warning shot. It is a signal that the investigation is maturing toward indictment.
The letter will often offer you the opportunity to testify before the grand jury. This is almost never in your interest. The grand jury room is the government’s room. No judge is present. No defense attorney is permitted inside with you. You walk in alone, answer questions under oath, and everything you say can be used to build the case against you or someone else. If you need to consult with counsel, you must stop, leave the room, get advice in the hallway, and return. The Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination applies in full — and invoking it is frequently the correct decision.
The single most important action upon receiving a target letter is to retain experienced federal criminal defense counsel immediately — and to say nothing to anyone else first. Do not call the prosecutor to explain. Do not discuss the investigation with colleagues, family, or friends. Every conversation you have outside the attorney-client relationship is a potential witness statement the government can use. The window between a target letter and a grand jury indictment is often the best opportunity to influence how this ends. Pre-indictment representation can affect what charges are brought, whether charges are brought at all, and the posture of the entire case if it proceeds to trial. That window closes when an indictment is returned. Do not wait.
April 16, 2026
Firm News
Welcome to Law Notes
This space will track Fifth Circuit rulings, federal sentencing guideline amendments, and significant developments in federal criminal law that affect clients in our practice areas. We will analyze decisions from the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, note Sentencing Commission amendments as they take effect, and flag developments in grand jury practice, constitutional criminal procedure, and international matters. Check back as new decisions and updates are published.